How To Choose The Right Cruise – The Ultimate Cruise Guide
Thinking about a cruise holiday but not sure how to choose the right cruise? My ultimate cruise guide should help.
Cruising has become one of the most exciting ways to travel, with new ships launching every year and offering ever more innovative facilities at sea. From floating parks and fine dining to race tracks and rooftop pools, today’s cruise ships are destinations in themselves. But with so many options, choosing the right cruise can feel overwhelming, especially if it’s your first time. That’s where my ultimate cruise guide comes in.
Whether you’re drawn to the world’s largest ship, Royal Caribbean’s Icon of the seas or Star of the Seas with its eight neighbourhoods and 20,000-plant Central Park, Norwegian Encore with its top-deck race track, or Celebrity Edge with its unique floating dining platform, this cruise guide will help you make sense of the choices and pick the cruise that’s perfect for you.
Cruising has changed dramatically in the last number of years. What was once considered the ideal vacation for retired couples, cruising has evolved to become more popular with families and the luxury market. Gone are the days when you had to sit with strangers for dinner, wearing your finest ball gown. While formal nights are still popular on some cruise lines, you can choose whether to embrace them or not.
I have seen many cruise ships over the years and I can honestly say there is a cruise for everyone. However, knowing how to choose the right cruise line to suit your style, requires a lot of planning. The quote ‘the journey is the destination’ springs to mind. It is not only the destination that you need to consider, the cruise line, cruise ship, and time of year are equally as important.
My ultimate cruise guide should give you some tips and tricks on how to choose the right cruise, however, I recommend engaging with a cruise expert to book your cruise holiday. They will be able to recommend the right cruise to suit your own taste and budget, and will be able to book the right flights and transfers to meet the cruise. With so many options available, this cruise guide is designed to make your decision simple and stress-free.
How to choose the right cruise ship
A mistake that is often made when choosing a cruise is that people assume that the cruise line is the most important component of your cruise holiday. I believe the cruise ship and time of year you are travelling are equally, if not more important.
Just because you liked cruising on Royal Caribbean’s Jewel of the Seas in the Caribbean in February, this does not necessarily mean you will like cruising on Royal Caribbean’s Wonder of the Seas in the Mediterranean in July.
Jewel of the Seas can hold 3,500 passengers and crew, but Wonder of the Seas can hold almost 9,300 passengers and crew. Both will offer a completely different cruise experience. Cruise ships are often referred to as floating hotels, but just as hotels vary greatly in size and standard, so do cruise ships.
There are some larger ships that can carry up to 9000 passengers, as well as intimate river cruises, that carry 150 passengers.
Six Questions to Help You Choose the Right Cruise:
1. What type of holidays do you like?
The first thing to ask yourself is this: When you go on holidays do you prefer to stay in a boutique hotel and dine out somewhere new each night, or is a lively all-inclusive resort more your style? There are cruise ships to suit families and thrill seekers, as well as more intimate cruises with exclusive spas and adult-only pools.
Pool games and karaoke bars might appeal to some, while others like West End style shows and live music. I loved the Aqua Theatre on Royal Caribbean’s Oasis Class ships and the late night outdoor bar on MSC Seaview. I also loved the relaxed atmosphere on Sky Princess.
My favourite cruise experience was on Celebrity Beyond. I loved it modern design and relaxed atmosphere, but if I was travelling with younger children I would probably choose a different cruise ship.
2. What time of year are you travelling?
Mediterranean cruises tend to attract a lot of families during the summer months, while Caribbean cruises in the winter attract lots of couples. Couples should avoid Easter holidays / Spring Break in the USA, and while Mediterranean cruises are very well priced in the winter time, do you want to be cruising the Med on a cold November day? Choosing the right cruise destination is very important and will make or break your holiday.
3. What is included in the cost of a cruise?
Cruises vary in price and standard but one of the main things to consider is what is included in the cost. Most packages are more expensive to book on board so always try to get these included in the cost of your cruise.
If you are booking an all-inclusive cruise, check what the drinks package includes. Most ships have a variety of drinks packages available and you may need to opt for the premium alcoholic beverages package depending on what your favourite tipple is.
If drinks are not included in the cost, I recommend pre-purchasing a drinks package in advance, as drinks prices can be expensive on board.
Check if gratuities are included and pre pay these if possible too. The recommended tip amount is 20% with many cruise lines, so pre-paying gratuities can be a massive advantage.
4. How many days are you at sea?
If you are cruising the Med you will likely be stopping in a different port each day. You may want to dine out when in port and therefore not feel the need to pre-purchase a speciality dining package.
However, if you are on a transatlantic cruise or have lots of days at sea you may not want to eat in the main dining room or buffet restaurant for lunch and dinner every day. If that is the case it might be an idea to pre-book a speciality dining package in advance.
The same applies to WiFi. You should be able to check emails and messages when in port so you may not need to pre-purchase WiFi if cruising the Mediterranean. However, the opposite applies if you have lots of days at sea.
I hope my top tips for booking cruise holidays have been helpful. I have listed some of my favourite cruises for first-time cruisers, couples and families below to help you choose the right cruise.
5. How old is the cruise ship?
I was on some of MSC’s older cruise ships and didn’t like their dark interiors and traditional decor. However, when I cruised on MSC Seaview I had a completely different experience. MSC Seaview is bright, airy, elegant and sophisticated – she completely changed my view on MSC Cruises.
TOP TIP: If you are booking an older cruise ship, check when it was last refurbished and read the latest reviews to know what to expect.
Read: MSC Seaview cruise guide and review
6. What is the dress code?
Formal nights may be common on most ships but this does not mean you need to wear black tie. In fact I have cruised on many ships and have rarely seen anyone wear Black Tie suit or full length ball gown.
Royal Caribbean have one or two formal nights over a seven day cruise. If you don’t want to dress up, you can avoid these in most cases, by going to the buffet restaurant for dinner.
Norwegian Cruise Line offer a freestyle cruise concept where it is casual and relaxed throughout. There are no set times for dinner and no dress code, so for clients that do not want to dress up at all, this is ideal.
Cunard and P&O Cruises are more strict on their formal nights and encourage it for their guests. Cunard even offer masquerade balls, and the Royal Ascot Ball.
Choosing a Cruise That Suits You Best
Whether you’re planning to take the whole family on a cruise adventure, unwind on a luxurious ship, or tick off your bucket list, this cruise guide has you covered. From luxury liners to thrilling adventure sailings, it provides everything you need to know before booking your perfect holiday.
Best cruises for first timers:
Choosing your first cruise can feel overwhelming and often requires plenty of research. Many first-time cruisers worry they might not enjoy the experience, so they often opt for a mainstream cruise that won’t break the bank. This is completely understandable, but according to statistics, over 90% of first-time cruisers end up wanting to sail again. This cruise guide will help you navigate your options and make your first cruise a memorable one.
A seven-night Mediterranean Cruise is always a firm favourite for first time cruisers. Flights are plentiful and usually inexpensive making them great value and easily accessible.
There are a variety of Mediterranean itineraries to choose from – Western Mediterranean cruises visit Spain, France and Italy, while Eastern Mediterranean cruises visit the Greek Isles, Croatia, Italy and sometimes Turkey and Montenegro too.
Marella Cruises, part of the TUI holiday group, offer great value all inclusive cruises with flights, transfers and checked baggage all included in the cost.
Royal Caribbean, Norwegian, MSC and Princess Cruises are the most popular with Irish holiday makers during the summer season. However, it is important to remember that Mediterranean cruises are very popular with families during July and August.
Mega ships can be a bit daunting for first time cruisers, so it might be a good idea to try one of the main cruise lines’ smaller ships. Royal Caribbean’s Independence of the Seas is still a massive cruise ship, but carries 4370 guests versus almost 7600 on the Icon of the Seas.
Princess Cruises offer kids clubs and entertainment for children, but they don’t tend to have waterparks, surf simulators or virtual reality games rooms, and therefore can be better suited for couples looking to cruise the Med in the summer time. Princess Cruises relaxed style will also suit first timers looking for great food and service.
For couples or friends looking for a more luxurious option Celebrity Cruises’ 5-star Edge class ships are cruising the Med this summer.
Best cruises for families:
Planning a trip for the whole family? This cruise guide highlights the best ships, destinations, and activities for every age. Contrary to what you might think, cruises are a fantastic choice for families, offering excellent value for money, with food, entertainment, and most children’s activities included in the price.
We have enjoyed a few family cruises and I loved to see my children using their independence enjoying various activities on board, while I relaxed by the pool. I never worried that they will get lost, and if you choose the right cruise will never hear your children say ‘I’m Bored!’
MSC Cruises offer fantastic value for families – kids travel free up to the age of 18 once sharing a cabin with their parents. MSC Meraviglia and Seaside-Class ships have aqua parks and virtual reality games rooms on board, and many of their cruise ships have Lego play areas.
Norwegian Cruise Line offer great value all-inclusive cruises that are packed with adventure. Most of the newer ships have waterparks, kids clubs and teen zones.
Norwegian Encore has a race track on the top deck, and I was the first person to test drive it! The race track is 1,150 feet long, sprawls over two decks and extends up to 13 feet over the side of the ship – it really is hard to fathom unless you see it, or in my case race it.
There is also an outdoor laser tag arena and an indoor room with high-tech virtual reality games that is like nothing else I have seen on a cruise ship – this is a teenagers dream!
Read: My review of Norwegian Encore
Royal Caribbean are renowned for their family friendly cruise ships. With everything from water parks, surf simulators, zip lines and even sky diving simulators. Royal Caribbean also have a private island in the Bahamas with a water park on site, making a Bahamas cruise an ideal extension to a family holiday in Orlando.
Read: My review of Harmony of the Seas
Read: 10 reasons to choose Royal Caribbean for family cruises
Disney cruises are ideal for families with young children, although there are also tween and teen clubs on board. Theme days like Star Wars and Marvel days are big hits with families, and getting the chance to meet your favourite Disney characters on board is a dream come true for many children.
Read: My review of Disney Magic cruise ship
Best cruises for young couples:
Mediterranean and Caribbean cruises are the most popular with young people. This cruise guide highlights some of the favourites, including newer ships from Royal Caribbean, Norwegian Cruise Line, and MSC Cruises, which offer excellent entertainment, nightclubs, and lively pool areas. If you prefer a quieter pool experience, be sure to avoid sailing during school holidays.
Royal Caribbean’s Oasis Class ships have seven different neighbourhoods, including the Boardwalk, and Central Park which is lined with trees and speciality dining options. You can fly across the ship on a zip line, enjoy surfing in the Flowrider, try your had at ice skating or rock climbing, and slide down the Ultimate Abyss.
With robots serving you drinks from the bar, and a superb outdoor Aqua Theatre, they are a great choice for a young couple looking for some adventure, modern style. However, drinks packages are expensive with Royal Caribbean, so make sure to book these in advance to secure the best value – see more on this below.
Norwegian cruise ships are also very popular with young couples as they offer great value all-inclusive rates. Despite the name, Norwegian Cruise Line is an American cruise line, and is similar in style to Royal Caribbean with a wide range of activities on board.
Norwegian Encore has a race track on the top deck. Norwegian Epic is renowned for its lively atmosphere. There are 12 bars including an Ice Bar and an outdoor night club, as well as top performances by bands such as the Blue Man Group.
I loved the expansive outdoor space on MSC Seaview. She has 20 different bars and lounges but my favourite was the Sunset Bar which played music until the early hours.
Carnival Cruise Line are a good choice for young people looking for a lively cruise in the Caribbean, while Virgin Voyages unique adult-only cruises are perfect for couples who don’t want to share the sun decks with young children.
Best cruises for older couples:
Older couples have the pick of the crop as they can usually travel at any time. Princess Cruises are a popular choice for four-star ocean cruises while Celebrity Cruises are arguably the best choice for those looking for a more luxurious option.
As well as the Mediterranean, Norwegian Fjords and Baltic Capitals cruises are popular for couples who don’t want to travel long distance. However, if flying time is not an issue, you can’t beat Alaska for the dream destination for older couples.
More intimate cruises on a small ship and the ability to dock in the heart of cities, has made river cruising one of the fastest growing sectors within the cruise industry. They tend to attract an older age group than ocean cruises, and are a great way to find out if cruising is right for you.
Travelmarvel River cruises offer great value 4-star river cruises which are ideal for couples or solo travellers who want to try a cruise for the first time.
Uniworld and Riviera are the more luxurious choice and offer a selection of 5-star river cruises. These cruise ships feature lavish designs, and offer fine dining and outstanding service.
Read: A river cruise on Uniworld’s SS Antoinette
For the ultimate bucket list adventure, take a transatlantic voyage on the Queen Mary 2. It is a very different feel and experience on board to other cruise ships, where dressing for dinner is still the norm.
Best luxury cruises:
Knowing how to choose the right cruise for a luxury experience is probably the most difficult. Silversea, Regent, Seabourn and Crystal cruises are the market leaders in luxury ocean cruising, however if you seek the luxury yacht feel then the smaller Silversea or Explora Journeys cruises will offer a first-class experience.
I loved Celebrity Cruises relaxed modern style and are more reasonably priced than the above mentioned. Their food and service is excellent and the overall feeling is less formal than some of the other luxury ocean cruise lines.
If river cruising is what you seek, Uniworld and Riviera offer 5-star all inclusive river cruises with fine dining and outstanding service, taking you to enchanting destinations such as the vineyards of Bordeaux, the fairytale castles along the Rhine, the historic cities of Vienna and Budapest and the picturesque villages along the Danube.
Best cruises for adventure:
Expedition cruising is growing more and more popular with many choosing to cruise to incredible places that are not easily reached by land or air – Antarctica and the Galapagos Islands being two of the favourites.
Celebrity Cruises Xpedition ship is the luxury ship for adventurers but you will need to plan way in advance, this ship can get booked up as soon as it goes on sale.
Hurtigruten will help you search for the Northern Lights. They are not luxury cruise lines and do not offer the same facilities on board as some of the main stream cruise lines, but they are truly made for adventurers. The stunning scenery and the true local experiences have made them extremely popular in recent years.
Read: 25 bucket list holidays around the world
Best cruises for food lovers:
I have found the quality of food on board most cruise ships to be generally very good, however I was very impressed with the variety of food on Sky Princess – both the complimentary and speciality dining options were excellent.
Read: My Sky Princess cruise guide to dining and facilities
If you are looking for a five-star large cruise experience, you will find it hard to beat Celebrity Cruises Edge Class ships. There are four different main dining rooms on board, which gives the impression you are dining in a speciality restaurant, without having to pay any additional costs.
However, food lovers such not miss the opportunity to dine on the Magic Carpet. This takes al-fresco dining to the next level. Favourite seafood dishes from RAW on 5 are served here which is one of Celebrity Cruises top speciality dining experiences.
Another unique experience is the use of 3D table animation in Qsine. As well as having the menu created by a Michelin Star Chef, your table comes to life with Le Petit Chef experience – this is available on Celebrity Edge Class ships.
For a more luxury cruise but on a more intimate scale, Silversea, Explora Journeys or one of the five-star river cruise lines such as Uniworld or Riviera, are sure to impress.
I hope my ultimate cruise guide will help you choose the right cruise lines for you. Remember to contact a specialist cruise travel agent who can suggest the best cruise to suit your travel style, taste and budget.
